Because it feels like the responsible thing to do.
Most of us who have done some form of self-development or leadership training have been told to act in a particular way when something happens that we think has gone wrong: don’t blame other people, and take radical responsibility. If we translate it, “Blame yourself for what has gone wrong.” It looks mature. It feels like control. But self-blame is still blame - the same verdict that something has gone wrong and someone is at fault, simply aimed at yourself.
I know this one from the inside
I used to beat myself up when a client didn’t get the results I thought they should. I would concentrate on what they should have experienced and then get stressed trying to work it out. I didn’t realise I was projecting my attachments onto them - or that what felt like responsibility was blame, pointed at me.
What self-blame sounds like
It rarely sounds like blame. It sounds sensible:
“I sabotaged myself.”
“I’m so stupid.”
“I made the wrong decision.”
“I’m my own worst enemy.”
“It’s all my fault.”
“I’ve done it again.”
“I shouldn’t have done that.”
Each one quietly splits you in two: a part that is in charge, and a part that is broken and has to be dealt with. Then the two parts fight.
Why it feels like the right thing to do
It sounds empowering because blaming ourselves is a way to feel in control. If it’s my fault, at least it’s mine to fix. And we have been given an infinite number of tools and techniques to cover up, or bury deeper into our psyche all of those painful statements.
The issue is, our solutions have centred around “STOP blaming!” Not realising this is us just finding another thing to blame - blame itself. When you combine it with take radical responsibility for our lives, the blame has nowhere left to go but inward. It becomes a way to blame ourselves for not being a good enough parent, boss or friend. We land up thinking everything is our fault.
Life then feels like an exhausting washing machine.
Why “stop blaming yourself” rarely works
Using self-control and willpower doesn’t work in the long run for other addictions, so why would it work for blame? It doesn’t.
Even if you manage to be 1000 days clean, which is an amazing achievement, it hasn’t taken away the craving. It just requires more and more valuable energy to feed the willpower. The fear of relapse can become all encompassing. Life becomes a battle where you are surviving one day at a time. Blaming blame places that blame onto our shoulders. It is a very heavy burden to carry. Why? It is control trying to get you out of something control helped to build.
The third option
Self-blame is still blame. There is a third option available that isn’t blaming yourself or others.
It is about getting uncomfortably self-honest: being curious about your contribution to what happened, without declaring yourself guilty or defective.
It isn’t letting yourself or others off the hook. It isn’t justifying what someone did. It is about exiting the Victim Cycle and becoming curious about our part. All the while taking into account that blame comes with a compounding effect. The longer we play the waiting game. The longer we ignore the signs. Or keep trying to hold back our truth. The more extreme the experience can become.
Where self-blame asks “What’s wrong with me?”, self-honesty asks a quieter question: what was honestly going on here for me - not others? It is easy to analyse others, but Blame Recovery is about you. Looking at your conscious or unconscious contribution to what occurred.
It is a much larger topic to cover here. But for now…
A small experiment
Next time you hear yourself say “I’ve done it again”, or “I’m so stupid”, get curious even if you want to argue. You see, blame simply means that you think something did or will go wrong. And this could be the foundation of all our stress and pain. And maybe we jump to this conclusion without all the information, awareness or wisdom. So either before, or after your anger has come out, when you are ready to honestly self-reflect, ask these instead:
What exactly do I think has gone wrong?
Did all of me want what I said I wanted - at that time, under those conditions?
What else mattered to me?
What was my honest endgame, priority or desire?
You may find the answer is less “I failed” and more “I wasn’t fully honest about what I wanted”. Or you were more afraid of something than you were prepared to say out loud. That isn’t a verdict. It’s information.
In short
Self-blame feels like responsibility, but it is the same verdict as blame, aimed inward.
Trying to stop it by force usually pushes it deeper down.
The third option is getting curious about your self-honest contribution, endgame, priority, desire.
If you’d like to go further, this is what my book, The Blame Game, is about. You might also like What is blame addiction? And if this was enough for today, that’s fine too.