Something happens that didn't go to plan, and the blame reflex kicks in: "Something went wrong." The pitch you worked on for weeks goes to a competitor. The conversation you rehearsed in the car turns into a bigger argument than expected. Your child slams a door and you hear yourself sounding exactly like your own father.
And almost at once, a trained voice arrives: What can I learn from this?
It sounds like the healthiest question in the world. It's on office posters, in leadership programmes, in half the books on my shelves. I want to look at the one word it quietly depends on.
Mistake is blame in disguise
Before we can learn anything from a perceived 'mistake', we have to decide that's what it was. Something went wrong. Someone - including us - should have done better. That decision happens so fast we don't notice it, but it is a verdict. And the verdict is blame.
In The Blame Game I put it like this: "the 'learn from your mistakes' mantra actually creates the very things it tries to avoid: that is, more situations and experiences that will be referred to as mistakes."
The blame reflex means you don't access all the information, awareness, wisdom and self-honesty that is available.
Watch what it does over time. Every lesson begins with a small conviction. Collect enough of them and you have a blame-based record that slowly closes your mind. People with a long record of their so-called mistakes don't usually become wiser. They become careful and avoidant, putting up more walls. Then fear (anxiety) becomes the fuel for frustration, and the verdicts get bigger: "I'm never doing that again." "I should have known better." "I'm never asking for your help again!"
So what if you left out the verdict?
Not "it was fine". Not positive thinking, not pretending it didn't hurt, and not doubling down on being stoic. Just be open to something different at the first step. Rather than this shouldn't have happened, ask a different question:
What is this showing me? What self-honesty is trying to make itself known?
Maybe the pitch went elsewhere because a bigger part of you never wanted that client. Maybe you didn't have the resources to serve them to your standard. Maybe the conversation turned into an argument because you'd been saying yes to something for months that you meant no to. It could be the catalyst for that relationship to end, or to grow into a deeper connection.
This way you're free to do the same thing again - and it may turn out differently, because the situation is different. It isn't about never doing it again. It's about recognising the influence blame had on what happened.
If you try this on something you think went "wrong" this week, I'd like to hear what you notice. You can ask me anything, or disagree with me, on my Goodreads page.
- Denis